A recent Wall Street Journal article provides some important insights into the developing fate of HillaryCare 2.0, the newly-unveiled universal healthcare proposals from Presidential candidate Hillary Clinton.
The first surprise, for me, at least, is that California Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger's healthcare plan was primarily designed by the same architect who designed HillaryCare 2.0- Laurie Rubiner. Ms. Rubiner has solid liberal-left wing credentials going back some years, including "directing health-care issues at the liberal New America Foundation," according to the Journal article.
Among the features shared by "ArnoldCare" and "HillaryCare 2.0," are: universal coverage mandates; ban on premium differentials based on actual health status; expansion of Medicaid, and; a requirement that insurers offer policies to all applicants.
The experiences of ArnoldCare suggest HillaryCare 2.0 could be in for a lot of trouble. The Democratically-controlled California legislature won't even pass the plan. According to the Journal's piece,
"It was too tax-heavy for Republicans and not nearly interventionist enough for Democrats."
Lots of people seem to believe that the next President just has to be a Democrat, because George Bush's poll numbers are so low. Then, they'll tell you that that Democrat has to be Hillary, because- well, here the reasons multiply, but essentially- it's "her" time, time for a woman to win the Oval Office, she's punched her ticket in the Senate, yada yada.
I think these people conveniently forget that, in some cases, what the candidate stands for, by her/himself, will actually matter. It seems to me that the same people who criticize Fred Thompson for only having character or values, and no detailed plans, overlook Hillary's total absence of declared values, and her implied, totally-political and calculating character.
This time, however, Hillary may have made a big mistake. She's once again revealed her core socialist stripes, by floating a national universal healthcare program devoid of market elements, aping an ailing approach that the largest state in the Union can't manage to implement.
Now, we discover the plans really are so alike because they share a common architect- Laurie Rubiner.
I wouldn't bet on Hillary just yet. She seems to have a whole year left in which to make some career-limiting mistakes, on the campaign trail to the White House in 2009.
Showing posts with label Schwarzenegger. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Schwarzenegger. Show all posts
Monday, September 24, 2007
Saturday, August 18, 2007
California's Universal Healthcare Debacle
Wednesday's Wall Street Journal carried two articles on the editorial page regarding universal healthcare.
The lead editorial described the failure of California's legislature to fund and pass Governor Schwarzenegger's universal healthcare plan. After all the misrepresentations and half-truths are peeled back, even the liberal Democratic California legislature won't risk passing it.
Between the "guaranteed issue" provision requiring insurers to cover everyone, and the mandatory enrollment, a 3.5% payroll tax, a $3.7B annual subsidy from the Federal government, and taxes of 2% and 4% on doctors and hospitals, respectively, the plan taxes and raises enormous amounts of money to solve what is estimated by what Stanford researchers estimate to be an uncovered cost of medical care in the state amounting to only 2.8% of the medical premiums in the state in 2000.
Essentially, Schwarzenegger's grand scheme is already collapsing under its own fiscal weight. Much like those of Illinois, Wisconsin, Tennessee and Pennsylvania before it.
It would be comforting to think that, having observed these large state laboratories struggle, and fail, to find a formula to make universal healthcare work, the Democrats' drive to install it at the Federal level would end. But, that's probably too optimistic in this election cycle, when even a Republican, Mitt Romney, mistakenly backed a similar program while governor of Massachusetts.
The lead editorial described the failure of California's legislature to fund and pass Governor Schwarzenegger's universal healthcare plan. After all the misrepresentations and half-truths are peeled back, even the liberal Democratic California legislature won't risk passing it.
Between the "guaranteed issue" provision requiring insurers to cover everyone, and the mandatory enrollment, a 3.5% payroll tax, a $3.7B annual subsidy from the Federal government, and taxes of 2% and 4% on doctors and hospitals, respectively, the plan taxes and raises enormous amounts of money to solve what is estimated by what Stanford researchers estimate to be an uncovered cost of medical care in the state amounting to only 2.8% of the medical premiums in the state in 2000.
Essentially, Schwarzenegger's grand scheme is already collapsing under its own fiscal weight. Much like those of Illinois, Wisconsin, Tennessee and Pennsylvania before it.
It would be comforting to think that, having observed these large state laboratories struggle, and fail, to find a formula to make universal healthcare work, the Democrats' drive to install it at the Federal level would end. But, that's probably too optimistic in this election cycle, when even a Republican, Mitt Romney, mistakenly backed a similar program while governor of Massachusetts.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)