“No Man’s life liberty or property is safe while the legislature is in session”.

- attributed to NY State Judge Gideon Tucker



Wednesday, May 6, 2009

Blaming America

The Wall Street Journal's Dorothy Rabinowitz wrote a wonderful column on April 22nd entitled "Obama Blames America."

Her editorial catalogues the new low to which our current president has sunk in his serial and expansive, named criticism of those who have preceded him in the office, including George W. Bush and Harry Truman.

The president's lengthy confessions of imagined sins of America to audiences abroad speak, once more, to his self-delusional rock star image, which evidently has replaced, if it ever were present, the self-image of representing our country as its senior statesman.

I believe Ms. Rabinowitz is correct when she closes her piece with the passage,

"Since that bridge too far to Europe, ordinary Americans, including some who voted for Mr. Obama, have shown evidence of a quiet but durable resentment over the list of grievances against the United States that the president brought to the world's attention while overseas. There are certain things that can't be taken back. There are images that are hard to forget. Anger of this kind has an enduring power that could, in the end, haunt this presidency."

It's a big mistake for a president to presume a mandate that was never given, nor won. Despite Wonderboy's remonstration to Republican Congressman Eric Cantor that the former can ignore the latter's suggestions because "I won," it doesn't work that way, for long, in our democracy.

He didn't win a mandate to repudiate every, or any, former presidents' actions. As many of my friends, and several pundits have remarked, that is a distinguishing characteristic of a banana republic, i.e., the criminalization of policy disagreements.

Most Americans didn't vote for a president so that he could accuse their country of imagined sins, simply to curry favor with foreigners. Anyone who criticizes Harry Truman's decision to use the atomic bomb merely displays his incredible ignorance of the realities of the time, and of the history of that era.

Can you imagine those overseas speeches in which he blames America for various sins being used in upcoming campaigns?

Such a person is, I think, simply unfit to hold the office of president. As Ms. Rabinowitz suggests, these faux-confessions are very likely to have a seriously negative effect on this president in the next months and several years.

Monday, May 4, 2009

What's In A Name? The New Progressives

It's funny how the manner in which something is named can be so important, yet misleading.

Take, for example, the early-twentieth century "Progressive" movement. In reality, as a recent Wall Street Journal book review noted, as has Judge Andrew Napolitano on Fox News, the movement was nothing less than anti-Constitutional.

Would many Americans have flocked to the "anti-Constitutionalists" banner? Probably nowhere near as many as backed the Progressive movement.

In fact, the term has become so twisted and misunderstood that Hillary Clinton labeled herself a "Progressive," and, in the same speech before Congress, went on to heap accolades on the founder of Planned Parenthood, Margaret Sanger, as an earlier Progressive who was as important to our Republic as Thomas Jefferson. But a guest on a Fox News program discussed her recent book about Sanger, exposing the latter as a proponent of eugenics. The discussion revealed that Sanger's movement was primarily aimed at one group controlling another's reproductive rights. The author displayed photos from her book showing Sanger speaking at Klan rallies. Stripped to its essence, the birth control movement was- and still often is- all about limiting the propagation of the poor, or anyone else considered unfit by those who can exercise such control.

If Planned Parenthood were called, instead, "Birth Control for the Lower Classes," how many in this country would back government funding for its initiatives?

The fight over abortion is similar. Mainstream media always refer to those supporting the delivery of fetuses as "anti-abortion," rather than "pro-life." Using the 'anti' descriptor conveys a sense of negativism and nihilism.

For those of us with good educations who are well-read, these names are less misleading. But for many others who vote, the naming conventions matter. It sounds modern and sensible to be 'progressive,' until you learn more about some of the values and explicit intent of the founders of the movement, including Teddy Roosevelt and Woodrow Wilson.

There's an unfortunate strain of rights-trampling populism in our country's history that seems to raise its ugly head in times of economic strains. The socialism of FDR occurred at such a time, as did Huey Long's companion campaign for the common man. In no time at all, the good of the masses is used as a reason to begin removing protections for individual rights to property and liberty which are enshrined in our Constitution.

Thus, it's troubling, yet not surprising, to hear Hillary Clinton declare herself a new Progressive. The values she's displayed since her husband's presidency certainly align her with those who would strip us all of our individual liberties for the benefit of the masses.

Sunday, May 3, 2009

The Real Problem with Wonderboy's Agenda

I wrote this post Friday on the topic of the speed and nature of Wonderboy's administration's efforts to engineer social change in the US.

However, in discussing this again, at length, with a friend this weekend, he related Ben Stein's comments on a recent appearance on Neil Cavuto's Fox News program.

Stein noted that the underlying problem with this administration, the prior one, and the Congress, is its unconstitutional behavior.

The takings of AIG, summary firing of GM's CEO, without being a shareholder, and forcible injection of government into our large banks, are all basically violations of the Constitution.

Friday's Glenn Beck program reiterated this. His studio audience, drawn from tax day tea parties, unanimously voiced a dissatisfaction with the manner in which neither party, nor the major media, will listen to the concerns of average voters. Or their complaints that so much of the federal government's recent behavior is simply not constitutional.

This seems to be the primary concern. If there were open, long and deep debate about major policy changes, e.g., energy, health care, financial industry structure, transportation, large deficit spending, that would be one thing. If Congressmen were spending significant time with their constituents and state governments discussing the costs, benefits and merits of these programs, at least voters would feel that their elected representatives were seriously airing the impacts of changes.

Instead, the whole matter has the feel of a unilateral federal imposition of some disembodied will on an unconsulted electorate.

The nature of recent federal action, including president Bush's last year, has been ever more intrusion by government into the private sector, rather than erring on the side of more personal freedom and rights.

With Bush, it was, I think, more accident and short-termism than carefully planned federal expansion. With Wonderboy, I think it's the latter. And so, I think, do a lot of other voters.

Friday, May 1, 2009

The Folly Of Avoiding Debate On Social Change

This week has been full of nonsensical pomp and arrogance surrounding Wonderboy's first 100 days in office.


Of course the comparison is always made with FDR. In Wonderboy's case, he actually thinks he is another FDR. Or JFK. Or maybe Lincoln. We never know which he'll choose to embody on any given day, so stricken with his own rock-star persona.


FDR, however, had actual government experience of some substantial nature prior to running for president. He served as Secretary of the Navy and governor of New York.

That experience notwithstanding, Roosevelt essentially failed in his management of the Depression. Sure, now he is remembered for all the socialist programs and changes to society and government which remain: Social Security, insured bank deposits, and the SEC, to name a few.

What are now largely forgotten, but was still taught in my youth, were: court packing, the unconstitutional National Recovery Administration, the joke WPA and PWA. Yes, even in his own time, FDR was seen as a socialist of the first rank. The truth is that federal spending on armaments for WWII gradually pulled the US economy out of the Depression, not Roosevelt's programs. In fact, consumer spending didn't really affect the economy again until ten years later, after WWII's end, when pent-up demand and a returning workforce of ex-GI's caused economic dislocations.

Much of FDR's program was, as the Supreme Court ruled, unconstitutional. That's why he tried to pack the court, but failed, even with his own party in the majority. Even now, less actually remains of FDR's legacy than we imagine, for all the chaos it caused at the time. But the lasting impression of heavy federal government intervention is still with us.

That's what fueled LBJ's largely-failed Great Society. What hasn't been scuttled or modified has been generally seen to have either become bankrupt (social security, medicaid, medicare) or disastrously eroded key societal values (welfare programs and ADC).

To me, though, Wonderboy's 100 days is different. A colleague put his finger on it when he noted the accelerated pace of single-party-backed changes. The many executive orders overturning standing policies. The unread, but passed stimulus bill- the largest spending bill in our nation's history. A bill that is less about economic stimulus, and much, much more about radical social policy change cloaked in an anti-recession spending sheath. The recent budget bill.

Because of such obvious stiff-arming of Republican opposition, and conscious ignorance of that party's alternative proposals, we have essentially draconian social policy change at the whim of only one party in less than six months.

Our current First Rookie is just an empty suit with a racial ancestry that attracted the guilt vote of many non-blacks who should have known better. He has absolutely no experiential qualifications for the office he now holds, and it is showing. Thus, when I use the term 'whim,' I mean it in the worst way. None of what Wonderboy has proposed has any evidence of being appropriate or effective, from his Treasury Secretary's manipulation and intimidation of our banks to his administrations plans to undertake government-designed, wholesale change in our insurance, medical, automotive, financial and energy sectors.

Change of this nature is probably not lasting. It's too fast and autocratic to fit with our nation's representative and collaborative form of societal change through government. Perhaps even change that will bring about improper reaction.

The real danger, though, is what every Republic dreads. Change that comes faster than the election cycle.

One cannot help but think, with all the despotic plans our president has in mind, someone, somewhere, may react by attempting to assassinate him.

That could well be the price of tampering with the US economy and society too quickly, without allowing for meaningful Congressional debate and compromise.

Of course, such an event is wrong and not to be desired. No matter how much you despise and disrespect a president, settling scores from a gun barrel, as opposed to the ballot box, is bad for everyone in the long run.

But you can just feel the pressure building among disenfranchised, disenchanted voters whose elected representatives in Congress have effectively been ignored.

Wonderboy was elected by far less than a Reaganesque landslide. His margin of victory was only 6 percentage points. At least forty percent of the Senate and forty-one percent of the House are Republican, so to totally ignore those Congresspersons is to effectively ignore a significant percentage of Americans whom they represent. It's not like the GOP in Congress has only 15 or 25% of the seats.

As such, the Democratic party's decision to freeze out any ideas but their own, sanctioned and directed by Wonderboy, could have real, deadly consequences within the next four years. And that would be a tragedy for the overall, long term health of the American Republic.

Thursday, April 30, 2009

Wonderboy's Demonizing of Legitimate Creditors

I try not to watch Wonderboy's speeches. The mere sound of his voice sickens me, so I head for the 'mute' button as fast as possible.

However, this afternoon, CNBC replayed some of the First Rookie's noon speech concerning Chrysler.

If you ever needed more evidence of why government should not interfere in private sector affairs, that speech was it.

Not that the presidential limousines are Chryslers, but our new president assured the nation that he, too, loves Chrysler cars and hopes we all buy one.

Gee, don't you typically have to pay for advertising? Will Alan Mulalley be demanding equal Oval Office time for his company's cars? I guess Wonderboy could shill for GM, since his actions are making that company the next likely government-owned auto maker.

But the low point was when he demonized legitimate bondholders by claiming that they are the only ones not sacrificing enough for Chrysler's survival. As if that is some pre-destined good.

No, Wonderboy heaped public opprobrium on those who lent money to Chrysler with an expectation of repayment, and clear legal rights if that doesn't occur.

How is that a lawyer, as president, is taking the lead in using thuggery and recommending the explicit ignorance and breaking of laws?

Is this the change we were to believe in?

As bad as George Bush's economic policies were, beginning in late 2007 by not amending mark-to-market methodologies via executive order, Wonderboy is much, much worse.

He's publicly choosing not only which companies will win, and which will not be granted government funding. He now is turning to specific investor classes and calling for senior secured debt holders to relinquish their legal rights.

This is surely government gone way, way too far with intervention into the private sector.

Wednesday, April 29, 2009

Arlen Specter's Party Switch

Of course, the major political news today was Pennsylvania's former-Republican Senator Arlen Specter changing parties.

I listened to a host of pundits bantering with each other about the change.

How, if Norm Coleman loses in Minnesota, the Democrats can block a filibuster. That this is another sign of the Republican party imploding. That Pennsylvania is turning bluer, and the GOP won't get this seat back.

I guess I come away with the sense that what should happen, usually does. Specter hasn't been a reliable Republican for years. Nor, of course, for that matter are Susan Collins or Olympia Snowe. Or, to be honest, even John McCain.

Who really knows if Mitch McConnell could have whipped Specter into supporting GOP filibusters? Who knows if Harry Reid can get him to vote for cloture?

Anyway, the Senate Democrats have threatened to abuse the 'budget reconciliation' process for any bill on which they don't care to compromise.

If the Senate Republicans had held firm on the stimulus bill, it would at least have been a partisan split.

Maybe it's time the American voters learned, again, just what uncompromising liberal Democratic rule will be like for a few years. It seems that memories of the costly, inflation-ridden 1970s and failed social legislation of the 1960s are gone, or significantly dimmed.

It's well understood that Arlen Specter, aged and gaunt-looking, has been and intends to remain a career Senator. He was trailing his primary challenger, and probably would not have made it to the general election in 2010. His blather about the Republican party having veered to the right on him is a lie. He's been a liberal Republican, which is also known as a Northeast Republican moderate, since he was first elected.

I tend to feel that, if we must have parties, then let's have them mean something. Frequent defectors like Snowe, Specter and Collins make life difficult for the GOP. Despite the chortling of various liberal pundits that the Republican party is washed up, in trouble, in disarray, or any number of other phrases to celebrate its current Congressional weakness, parties naturally ebb and flow in power.

If a more honest culling of Republican Senators results in more focus on just what the party represents, maybe that's a good thing. There's nothing like dissatisfaction with the party in power to make the other party suddenly look a lot better, even if you don't agree with them on everything. The Congressional Democrats could pull that off yet next year.

Tuesday, April 28, 2009

NewsCorp Gets Tough on Obama

Holman Jenkins writes a weekly column each Wednesday in the Wall Street Journal. Last week, he ratcheted up the level of stridency in his criticism of the US president by exposing the folly of his positions on the GM mess.

Jenkins has typically been rather careful and indirect in his tone when dealing with politics. However, last week's column seemed to take his recent, more adversarial tone to a new height. Prior to this, he had probably reached his high-water mark by calling New York AG Andrew Cuomo a thug.

At the time, I suggested to colleagues that Jenkins' columns must now be vetted by Rupert Murdoch himself, because Jenkins' verbiage had escalated to the point that political recriminations surely would be considered by aggrieved parties.

Here are a few choice passages from Jenkins' column last week,

"It's good to be the king -- until you start tripping over your own robe.

So King Barack the Mild is finding as he tries to dictate the terms of what amounts to an out-of-court bankruptcy for Chrysler and GM. He wants Chrysler's secured lenders to give up their right to nearly full recovery in a bankruptcy in return for 15 cents on the dollar. They'd be crazy to do so, of course, except that these banks also happen to be beholden to the administration for TARP money.

Wasn't TARP supposed to be about restoring a healthy banking system? Isn't that a tad inconsistent with banks just voluntarily relinquishing valuable claims on borrowers? Don't ask.

His retainer, Steven Rattner, has delivered word that the king's pleasure is that these unsecured creditors give up 100% of their claims in return for GM stock.

It may also be the king's pleasure, he advised, to convert at some point the government's own $13 billion in bailout loans into GM stock.

There's just one problem: Why on earth would GM's creditors -- who include not just bondholders but the UAW's health-care trust -- want any part of this deal?

No wonder the king's mediation of 40 years of stalemated labor and business issues in the auto sector isn't going so well. There's a reason royal discretion has long been outmoded as a way to run an economy: Things just work better if a realm's subjects are left to resolve their own disputes and interests through the impersonal mechanism of the markets and the law.

King Barack has only been on his throne for three months. His policies already have devolved into savage incoherence.

But let's face it, the king is also somewhat lacking in the lion-heartedness department.

He's on record saying that the only sensible way to reduce fossil-fuel dependence is to put a price on it, as with cap and trade. Then why not have the courage of his convictions and do away with the proven ineffectualness and perversity of trying to regulate automotive fuel mileage directly?

King Barack could take a leaf from St. Jimmy the Simple, who faced a collapse of the railroad industry. He signed the Staggers deregulation law, returning power to the industry itself to decide what services to provide and which customers to chase. What had previously been an industrial basket case, halfway nationalized already, fixed itself almost overnight.

He might consult with the Sage of Omaha, who has become a fan of the rail business."

Hardly Jenkins' usual mild, irony-filled prose.

Add this to Bill O'Reilly's interrogation of Newsweek's publisher last night, in which he claimed that only Fox News and the Wall Street Journal, both Newscorp properties, are reporting honestly on the new administration, and you get a sense of something larger brewing in media-land.