“No Man’s life liberty or property is safe while the legislature is in session”.

- attributed to NY State Judge Gideon Tucker



Showing posts with label Conservatives. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Conservatives. Show all posts

Thursday, November 19, 2009

Liberals vs. Conservatives As Envy vs. Ambition

Lately, I've been giving a lot of thought to the differing core, underlying values and attitudes which must drive liberals and conservatives.

From my recent reading of Amity Schlaes' excellent book, "The Forgotten Man," current reading of Mark Levin's "Tyranny and Liberty," and frequent viewings of Glenn Beck's Fox News Channel program, it's been easier for me to reflect upon the circumstances surrounding the Founding Fathers' as they wrote the Constitution.

Nearly forgotten now is the struggle those men had in securing the freedom to engage in economic activity as they wished. In the mercantilism system of Great Britain of that time, colonies supplied natural resources and raw materials. Finished goods were largely prohibited to be manufactured. It's not well-recalled now, but in that day, machinery, machine tools and plans for machines were not allowed out of Britain to her colonies.

The Revolution which Americans fought against Britain was as much about economic freedom as it was about political freedom and fair representation to a taxing, governing authority.

In reading about the men who founded our country, there are various references to John Hancock as the colonies' wealthiest man. But you never hear him berated for that. Nor any speeches during the framing of the Constitution calling for punitive taxes on Hancock or his ilk.

Rather than attempt to take the wealth of men like Hancock, the new Republic's structure tried to allow for any other man to rise to similar levels of wealth. The concepts of opportunity and ambition vastly outweighed those of envy or jealousy.

Now, we seem to have reversed this. All we hear is that business people earning "too much" need to pay higher taxes. That the important issues are to provide income and health care to the poor.

No longer does anyone seem to recall that the minimalist Constitution was so written in order to allow everyone to realize the fruits of their own labor and best efforts. It wasn't to levelize incomes and redistribute the new country's total personal incomes.

In short, thanks to the past seventy years' of post-FDR liberal pressure, our Republic is now more focused on seeing envy of economic success given priority over each person's opportunity to realize their own economic and other dreams.

Ambition is given lip-service, while laws are crafted to carry out envy-driven wealth- and income-transfers.

If you can't keep the wealth you create in America, what motivation is there for the poor to improve themselves? Why would anyone labor if the fruits are evaluated and that declared 'excess' by some politician confiscated?

Truly, one can see much more clearly in the current environment that liberals are primarily governed by envy, rather than the individual's ambition to create her/his own better life through one's own labor and talents.

Friday, October 23, 2009

The Conundrum of The New Jersey Voter

It's tough to be a voter in New Jersey this year. One really feels there's no practical, quality choice in the gubernatorial election.

The Democrats are, of course, propping up failed liberal Jon Corzinne. After being kicked out as co-head of Goldman Sachs' years ago, Jon bought a New Jersey Senate seat. Tiring of that, and not expecting the Democrats to retake the upper chamber, he then bought the governor's seat.

Perhaps he thinks getting his ticket punched there, twice, gives him presidential credentials. Or maybe he's just bored with working for a living, so political elective office makes sense.

Who knows?

Either way, he's taken the wreckage left by the last governor, who resigned under an ethics cloud, and worsened it. New Jersey is probably closer behind California in its fiscal mess than most people, or state citizens, realize.

Then we have "Chris Christie."

What a guy! A product of the Christie (no relation) Todd Whitman-influenced state Republican party, he's been coached to alter his positions like a custom-made suit.

I never trust someone who flips on right-to-life issues suddenly, and without reason. Christie did this so that a pro-life stance, his original view, wouldn't hinder his chances in a solidly Blue state.

However, as an independent who registers Republican, even I can see how Christie is corrupt even before winning the governorship.

The reports of his cutting a deal to spare his brother an SEC prosecution ring true. So does his paying off Justice department cronies with no-bid contracts for outsourced legal work.

Sure, sure, he got a bunch of convictions as a federal prosecutor. Sure, so did Rudy Giuliani.

But I think the comparisons stop there.

You knew what Giuliani was for, and against, even if you didn't live in New York City. Christie merely mouths platitudes about lower taxes and spending, but offers no solid plans for such empty concepts.

This is a state in the choke-hold of lawyers, of either party, in the state legislature. It's going to take a lot to restore any shred of fiscal rectitude in the state.

Faced with these unappetizing choices, one considers the independent, Chris Daggett. Daggett actually details how he'll cut a range of taxes and extend the sales tax to more items, without raising the rate. Of course, there's no plan for spending cuts in his campaign, either.

But the real question is how to vote without feeling you've rewarded vagueness, incompetence, or corruption, or wasted your vote.

I can't vote for Corzinne. Just isn't going to happen. I never liked him or his policies, and they have demonstrably failed.

I voted for Lonnegan in the Republican primary. I don't like Christie, and I don't trust him. With only a prosecutorial career and no clear ideas on governing, voting for him is like buying a pig in a poke. And, no, I'm not poking fun at his weight or girth.

But I just have doubts about voting for Daggett. It's a classic prisoners' dilemma. If I knew a lot of other voters, disgusted with both of the other clowns, would choose Daggett, then so would I.

I mean, how much worse can things get? And several local and regional news organizations have endorsed his candidacy.

But if I vote for Daggett and Corzinne wins, then I did waste my vote.

but if I vote for Christie, I'm not voting with a clear conscience.

It's all very disturbing. A microcosm, really, of my disappointments with both parties on the national level, too.

Monday, September 21, 2009

Irving Kristol's Legacy

I am sure I read a lot of Irving Kristol's pieces in the Wall Street Journal since the late 1970s. However, I confess to not having fully understood his immense network of influential colleagues, until reading James Q. Wilson's editorial/obituary in yesterdays Journal.

Reading some excerpts from Kristol's Journal columns over the years, it's easy to see how he was so far ahead of others in critiquing the roots of LBJ's "Great Society."

Bill Buckley, who also died recently, was perhaps the more public face of the conservative movement. But Kristol seems to have attacked modern liberalism on more philosophically fundamental bases. I sometimes envy his son, Bill, for having had two such eminent, thoughtful writers as parents. Gertrude Himmelfarb, Irving Kristol's wife, authored a wonderful book some years ago, "The New History, and The Old."

I suppose because of Irving Kristols advanced age, and lack of active writing in recent years, and my own more tenuous connection with his earlier work, I can't truthfully say I will miss him.

Rather, I think I'm the beneficiary of both the work of his intellectual and philosophical progeny, and the modern blogging world that allows so many of them to continue his work in ever more approachable and effective ways.

Friday, September 11, 2009

The Conservatives' Legislative Mistakes

The current debacle over health care legislation points up an important error which Republican Party members of Congress and Presidents (Reagan, Bush and Bush) made over the past thirty years.

Beginning with their attaining a Senate majority in 1982 (?), Republicans should have moved to cement their preferred approaches to social security, medicare, medicaid, energy policy and health care into legislation. By 1994, when the Republicans took the House, as well, they were well-poised to draft and push preferred solutions to issues in these areas.

As a conservative, it's very sad to see, some twenty years after Reagan left office, that little of his term's accomplishments remain in place. Spending has gone wild, taxes are rising, and government is big and getting even bigger. The only lasting achievement seems to have been breaking up the old Soviet Union and its penchant for extending communism around the globe.

How different things would have been, had Reagan led by example and sent legislation to Congress to simplify and solidify, in law, health care reforms which, only now, his party's Congressional members are hastily finding the courage to champion?

Even to the point of pushing, during the George W. Bush's two terms, Constitutional amendments to effect key conservative objectives?

It's the same with energy policy, social security and medicare. The latter two are an ever-growing drag on the nation's economy and federal treasury. The former is something which, once and for all, should have been set on solid, clearly-conceived ground and then left to operate.

In the past, conservatives have obviously felt that the less they did and legislated, the better. They naively believed that others, specifically, liberal Democrats, would not continue to push for legislatively-based changes in these key areas of government and societal policy.

By leaving the topics unresolved through legislation, Republicans left themselves vulnerable to those whose mantra is to continue to encroach on individual liberties while enlarging the government's 'safety net.'

Perhaps this generation of Republican leaders, e.g., Paul Ryan and Eric Cantor, have finally learned this lesson and will move adroitly and quickly, when in power in the House, to fix in law conservative solutions to important social issues, the liberal approaches to which will cost infinitely more money and confiscate many more individual rights and liberties.

Monday, August 24, 2009

Why Do Liberals & Conservatives Betray Their Ideals?

Why do both liberals and conservatives initially identify with narrower bases of issues than they end up championing?

Liberals begin with concern for the poor and defenseless. They claim to want a safety net for all in society. In time, however, they move from providing means for them to simply making them dependent upon the state. And, once liberals succeed in making the poor, and others, wards of the state, they suddenly become concerned with how state funds are spent, and begin to control the lives of those they once wished to simply defend.


Genuine compassion for someone's poor lot in life morphs into controlling that life.


Conservatives likewise morph into something frightening.


They begin wanting individual liberty and freedom. They value economic freedom and the "freedom to fail." Often, they are willing to provide means to the poor, but not a free ride.


Somehow, along the way, they begin to equate liberty and freedom with a sort of old-timey libertarian desire for moral purity. They begin to preach against social change, and, in time, begin to legislate morality and values.

A movement initially dedicated to individual freedom begins to pass laws regulating personal freedoms and behaviors. They allege to be the arbiters of "family values."


Liberals, who initially desire more means for the poor and weak to live life, shift to controlling them and society at large


Conservatives, who initially desire freedom and liberty for all, along with consequences to each for his choices, in time, legislate private morality as social good, and also try to control people's lives.


They both betray their initial ideological purity by straying too far from their limited focus.

How are citizens to act if they truly desire freedom, and these two political movements are their only broad choices for government?

Monday, May 11, 2009

Regarding Jack Kemp

Jack Kemp's recent death has unleashed a torrent of punditry about what he did, or did not, stand for. Many in the media knew him, both as a Congressman, VP candidate, and HUD Secretary.

Kemp's explicit and solid pro-growth economic credentials typically caused him to be labeled as a conservative. Of course, his stance on social issues was more mainstream.

However, with his passing, many, like ditzy Wall Street Journal weekend columnist Peggy Noonan, are plunging, yet again, into diatribes about how the GOP needs to be more centrist and mainstream. This time, they bemoan the party's reaction to Arlen Specter's job-protection-induced switch to the Democrats, and claim that Kemp's legacy should be a bigger tent for the Republican party.

As far as I know, Kemp was on a losing GOP ticket with Bob Dole, the latter no solid conservative, either. I'm sure Jack Kemp was a good Representative for his district in Buffalo. The tax cut legislation that bore his name certainly was good for the country.

But I never actually heard Kemp scold the GOP for being too doctrinaire. If anything, I'd say the story about his celebratory letters to his grandchildren on Wonderboy's election indicates he was fooled by the candidate's attempts to portray himself as centrist, rather than the extreme liberal he actually is, and governs as.

Jack Kemp was a valuable member of the GOP for many years. But I don't think that means we should automatically attribute things to him that he didn't necessarily say, nor give all of his opinions the same weight as those of successful GOP presidential candidates.

Saturday, May 9, 2009

A Single Editorial Changes My Primary Vote

As June draws near, the New Jersey Republican party will select a candidate who will try to oust the failed Democratic governor, Jon Corzine.

As of a month ago, I don't think I really had any clear notion of whether I'd vote for Chris Christie, a former US attorney, or Steve Lonegan, a former Bergen county town mayor.

Beginning about a month ago, televised ads on cable channels began to appear in large numbers for Christie. It painted him as a desirable, attractive conservative candidate. He even appeared on Neil Cavuto's program on Fox News last week. In that appearance, Christie roundly criticized his opponent, Lonegan, as wanting to raise taxes.

Then I read this weekend Wall Street Journal's editorial, written by a columnist for the local newspaper. According to that piece, Christie is really a traditional New Jersey GOP moderate, in the vein of Whitman and Kean. That is, they are socially liberal and spend too much money, but want to cut taxes.

But even that isn't the worst of what I read about Christie. According to the Newark Star-Ledger's Paul Mulshine, Christie has had some questionable dealings with law firms during his years as a US attorney. It is alleged that sweetheart contracts were let to old colleagues, and that Christie's brother, Todd, was given a lighter sentence than others found guilty of illegal front running, in deference to Mr. Christie's position and influence.

There's always the question of Mr. Mulshine's own objectivity, given that the Star-Ledger is hardly a conservative paper.

But, in just a few minutes, my certainty about voting for Christie vanished. I'll have to do some digging online now to get a better sense of both candidates.

As bad as Corzine is- and he's totally inept- I don't want another rerun of Christie Whitman's moderate politics. This state needs serious damage control and repair, and fast. A moderate masquerading as a conservative just to win the GOP nomination for governor is not going to get the job done.

Friday, May 8, 2009

Who Cares What Colin Powell Thinks About The GOP?

A lot has been made this week of Colin Powell's somber judgments about the Republican party. Powell is the toast of the liberal media for claiming that the Republicans have lost their way and need to moderate, return to the political center, etc., etc., etc.

Excuse me, but didn't Powell support Wonderboy in the last election? Hardly what I'd call a solid conservative, is he? He cut and run over race.

And, if memory serves, Powell was the wimpy moderate at State who tried to mess up president Bush's strategies in his first term.

Powell has served in Republican administrations, but the further he's gotten from his army years, the more centrist and placating he's become. Nobody has ever accused him of having a strong conservative orientation.

As a British conservative guest on Hannity noted on Wednesday evening, nobody has ever heard Powell articulate a clear vision on anything. How can he possibly counsel the GOP on this?

Instead, as that guest, and Ann Coulter noted on O'Reilly, earlier that evening, the GOP is not the same as the size of group of Americans who consider themselves conservatives. The number of registered Republicans has always been less than the base that votes for the party's candidates. Especially in those states, one of in which I was raised (Illinois), which allow for voters to register as independents, but vote in the primary of their choice.

As one Fox News pundit noted, Reagan, and other successful candidates, succeed by moving the center to their end of the spectrum, not by moving to the center. For example, it was noted that Dole, McCain and Bush senior all lost election or re-election as moderates. The more the Republicans listen to the NY Times and move left, the more they get creamed.

Powell is completely wrong. Which is why the liberal media is playing up his comments so much. But Colin Powell is no conservative, and probably not a Republican, either.

Friday, February 13, 2009

Judd Gregg's Principled Choice

There's great cause for conservative joy and celebration today. Senator Judd Gregg of New Hampshire took a principled stand and declined to join Wonderboy's cabinet.

Gregg is a very classy, old-style, respectable man and Senator. He was much too gracious to speak the truth about what happened. But it's easy to read between the lines.

Between voting against the stimulus package, being repulsed by its excess and inappropriateness, and seeing his prospective department's main responsibility, the census, gutted and moved to Rahm Emanuel's office as a political activity, Gregg realized he was being played for a token conservative sucker.

So, rather than the First Rookie playing with Mitch McConnell's head, as a Wall Street Journal editorialist wrote a few weeks ago, it's exactly the reverse. One of the smartest, most conservative Republicans in the Senate reversed course, handed Wonderboy a huge defeat, and heads back to bolster a sane, principled GOP minority.

What Gregg didn't say, but is now obvious, is Wonderboy's bait wasn't enough, and his pretense at building a bipartisan cabinet is, and always was, a sham.

It's another well-deserved blunder and black eye for the First Rookie.

Friday, January 30, 2009

Rush Limbaugh Is Right: Obama Should Fail

Rush Limbaugh was right to state that he hopes the newly-elected President fails in his attempt to force the liberal agenda on this country.

For nearly eight years, liberals in Congress and outside of it loudly proclaimed their opposition to President George Bush and his initiatives. Only last session, the Democrat-controlled House and Senate attempted to hobble President Bush's successful prosecution of the war in Iraq.

Now, however, with the election of the New Messiah, dissent is no longer allowed. As I wrote in this post in May of last year,

"Thus, when you hear a Presidential candidate, e.g., Obama, call for "unity" on any issue aside from war, beware. That candidate means to rule without dissent.

"Unity" means, in other words,

'When I become President, I will dictate, and, in the name of 'unity,' you will comply and there will be no dissent. Dissent goes against unity. And unity will be the mantra by which I lead and enforce all my demands of Congress.'

Even Reagan didn't appeal for unity with his economic rescue of the country after Carter nearly ruined it, economically and militarily. He simply appealed to Americans to back his push for more economic freedom, lower taxes, less government spending, and a stronger defense."

This is indeed what Wonderboy is doing. He is demonizing any who would oppose him.

He stumped Congress, which everyone knows he already had in his pocket, thanks to his party's majorities in both Houses. He made a pretense of wanting bipartisanship, but his party's troops in both Houses have stiff-armed Republican ideas, then claimed that the GOP wouldn't compromise.

Limbaugh's article in yesterday's Wall Street Journal made a lot of sense. More than Wonderboy's bloated gigantic spending package.

What's amazing is how stupid the sitting President was to name Limbaugh when trying to shame Republican Congress members into voting for his bill. He elevated Rush to equal status with the President, and gave even more air time and credibility to the popular radio talk show host.

Criticizing Republicans for voting against his bill, and claiming they are simply being partisan, and blindly following Limbaugh, simply exposes Wonderboy for the fraud that he is. He won't brook debate or dissent.

Only last evening, a guest on one of Fox News' programs noted that this spending bill is the single largest appropriation ever voted on in Congress, yet only one hour of debate was allowed.

This is post-partisanship and unity? No, this is dictatorship.

Saturday, November 15, 2008

The Vigilant Opposition

One thing- perhaps the only thing- that is positive about Democrats controlling both Houses and the Oval Office is that, already, it is proving both enjoyable and easier to constructively criticize the incumbents and about-to-be-incumbents, then defend the imperfect GOP officials.


Fact is, no government is ever perfect. For the past eight years, one particular liberal Democratic acquaintance has picked on some detail each week, with which to attempt to bully and intimidate me regarding the Bush administration.


When the party with which I more closely identify, even if I refuse to consider myself a full-fledged Republican, is criticized, my natural reaction is to first decide whether or not it's a relevant, significant issue.


However, being in opposition now affords me the ability to be equally critical- all the time!


How satisfying to see the Illinois rookie already making gaffes within a week of his election! Like this one, here.

And this is only the first of many, many more to come. Especially given the Messianic fervor which which so many have invested magical powers in the unaccomplished, inexperienced President-elect.

Think of the staffing mistakes. The lack of proper administrative oversight and governance by someone who's never run so much as a lemonade stand in his life.

Yes, this is going to be a target-rich two- and four-year stint for us conservatives.

Monday, August 11, 2008

The $10Billion Question: Why Are Conservatives Always More Optimistic Than Liberals?

Yesterday's Wall Street Journal featured a fascinating editorial "on how to best allocate scarce resources to solve the world's problems."

Piggybacking on a recent piece by noted environmental issues expert Bjorn Lomborg in the Journal, Newt Gingrich and Jerry "Governor Moonbeam" Brown each provided their responses to the question of how to spend $10 billion of US resources over the next four years to "help improve the state of the world."

Here are the salient points in their replies. First, Gingrich's list:

Here are seven prizes, the first three at $2 billion tax free and the last four at $1 billion each tax free (tax free because not paying taxes makes these prizes psychologically worth much more):

1) A low-cost vaccine or preventive intervention for malaria -- possibly the single biggest potential improvement in the quality of life in poor tropical countries.
2) A modestly priced, mass-manufacturable hydrogen engine for cars, which would be the biggest single contribution to reducing carbon loading of the atmosphere and reducing subsidies through high oil prices to dictatorships.
3) A cheap method for turning large quantities of seawater into fresh water.
4) A reusable system that could get people into space at 10% of the current cost, thus enabling genuine space tourism and launching an age of exploration.
5) The first privately financed permanent lunar base.
6) A method for reusing nuclear waste to make Yucca Mountain, Nevada unnecessary as a repository.
7) A method of learning math and science that kids like, and that enables us to leapfrog India and China by breaking out of our unionized, bureaucratic curriculum. This would enable us to replace "No Child Left Behind" with a more effective education model that could be called "Every American Gets Ahead."


Then, "Moonbeam" Brown's:

I propose that we take the $10 billion and invest it in curbing our energy appetite through efficiency programs and incentives. The efficiency I envision would allow us to enhance our quality of life, but do so in ways that reduce the huge quantities of oil, gas and coal that we now consume.

California has kept its per capita electrical consumption flat for the past 25 years -- in significant part through appliance and buildings standards and incentives to adopt ways that get more work out of less energy. I am not talking about some collective hair shirt, but rather about a wide variety of new technologies and designs.


The world is facing a triple threat of unprecedented dimensions: First, the loss of cheap and easily discovered oil; second, explosive energy demand from China, India and other emerging countries as they rapidly improve their standard of living; and third, the climate disruptions caused by CO2 and other greenhouse gases. None of the three will go away. In fact, each will get progressively worse unless we take decisive action, without delay. America must take the lead in dealing with global energy and climate challenges, and at the same time vastly strengthen its own economy and security.

The next president should engage the appliance and equipment manufacturers and provide the kind of leadership that has so far been totally lacking.

Next, the federal government should establish a financial grant program, encouraging the states to craft efficiency standards for new buildings. Again, the example of California is instructive. Its detailed and regional building standards have saved Californians tens of billions of dollars in lower energy bills. A significant part of the proposed $10 billion could be spent on this type of effort. Each state would be asked to craft their own rules in response to the differing conditions found in various regions of the country.

A third type of program could be modeled on California's current system of rebates, tax credits and other incentives that encourage businesses and consumers to adopt efficiency measures that exceed the mandatory standards. This program is financed through the investor-owned utilities and established under the authority of the state utilities commission.

America is at a crossroads. Total U.S. financial and nonfinancial debt rose to $44.7 trillion in 2006, from $2.4 trillion in 1974. This does not even count longer-term liabilities such as Social Security and Medicare. Oil and gas are consuming more and more of our national wealth. It is time for our political and business leaders to tap into America's unspent creativity and entrepreneurial genius. Many times $10 billion will be needed. But it can be done. It must be done.

The first thing I notice about the two different replies is that Gingrich, as a typical conservative, optimistically believes that, given sufficient motivation, individuals will solve a wide range of problems which directly affect people living in the third world. This stems directly from Lomborg's earlier editorial and work with global leaders which demonstrated that the biggest 'bang for the buck' in improving life on our planet is to bring the poorest humans up on the socio-economic ladder, not to focus on rich country 'problems.'

In contrast, Moonbeam Brown immediately inserted his own liberal agenda into the situation. And, being a typical liberal, Brown sees disaster and 'crossroads' everywhere.

Ignoring his state's slide into economic chaos in the past decade, Brown mistakenly promotes California as the model which the rest of the planet should emulate.

Further, Brown, who is not an economist, engages in completely erroneous 'logic' to declare that, because Americans spend a lot on energy to generate economic value- more than any other country on the planet- energy must, therefore, be a 'problem.' A commodity whose usage must be curbed!

Viewed from a step back, it's clear that Brown's agenda is fraught with the usual liberal hand-wringing over imminent disasters from which we will only be saved by government intervention.

Yes, a bunch of unmotivated, retired-in-place civil servants who can't cut it in the private sector will be rescuing us from global environmental disaster.

Instead of this pipe dream, Gingrich wisely offers prizes which the most motivated, intelligent and creative humans may claim by simply solving the problems described.

Quite a stark, simple contrast between the optimistic conservative viewpoint, and the gloomy, distrustful liberal one, when it comes to life and human nature and creativity.

Sunday, May 11, 2008

Real Conservatism in Louisiana

Kim Strassel wrote a wonderful piece in her 'Potomac Watch' column in Friday's Wall Street Journal entitled "A Louisiana Lesson for the GOP."

In her piece, Ms. Strassel contrasted two Republican House candidates in the state. Both ran as 'conservatives,' but Strassel's column explains how misleading this name can be.

The losing candidate, Woody Jenkins, is described as,

"By the lazy standards of the GOP, Mr. Jenkins should've been a cinch to win a Baton Rouge district in Republican hands for 34 years, and that President Bush won with 59% in 2004. Their candidate was a rock-solid social conservative who, in 28 statehouse years, had never voted for a tax increase, and who wanted to erect a U.S.-Mexico wall.

Yet Mr. Jenkins was also a divisive firebrand. He was infamous for carrying around plastic fetuses, to demonstrate his opposition to abortion. He'd previously landed in a weird entanglement with former Ku Klux Klan leader David Duke. This history made even conservatives fidgety, and crowded out anything Mr. Jenkins had to say on issues.

More debilitating to the Jenkins campaign was a strong whiff of the ethical problems that have plagued Republicans. A labor union ran ads noting Mr. Jenkins's had seen 19 tax liens filed against him and his broadcasting company since 1990. The Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee pointed out that a murky Jenkins charity had paid him consulting fees, paid rent to his company, and paid more than a half-a-million dollars to his wife. He'd been in hot water over campaign contributions, and voted against financial disclosure.

Democrats, meanwhile, have realized it's more important to win than to impose liberal litmus tests on candidates. Mr. Jenkins's opponent, Don Cazayoux, was pro-life and pro-gun. He had nice things to say about John McCain, and rarely mentioned Mr. Obama or Hillary Clinton. A self-styled "John Breaux Democrat," he focused on education and health care."


As more independent than Republican, and more conservative fiscally than socially, I think I'd probably have voted for Cazayoux, too, were I a resident of that district.

Jenkins impresses me as the type of 'conservative' that gives the movement a bad name. Rather than focus on operational issues over which there is now wide disagreement, such as healthcare, what, if anything, the Federal government should do about energy policy, and the economy, Jenkins seems to have clung to old emotional issues like abortion.

In contrast, Ms. Strassel described another Louisiana House candidate for the GOP, Steve Scalise. About him, she wrote,

"The 43-year-old Republican, Steve Scalise, had pinpointed today's GOP vulnerabilities, and ran an anti-status-quo campaign. His focal point was wasteful spending, and he touted his legislation to reform Louisiana's earmark process. Another hallmark was ethics reform and his fight against public corruption. He talked up competitive private health care, lower taxes and school choice.

Republicans looking for an Obama doppelganger would have been better served by his Democratic competitor, Gilda Reed. She campaigned on immediate withdrawal from Iraq and "universal" health care. Trade came in for a bashing, as did secret ballots in union-organizing elections. Ms. Reed explained she was personally pro-life, but felt abortion needed to remain legal. Her cause became that of the liberal left, with the Daily Kos hosting an online fund-raiser on her behalf. Mr. Scalise won 75% of the vote."

This makes a lot of sense to me. Scalise focused on the issues that make a difference in his constituents' everyday lives. To me, that is espousing workable, salable conservatism to voters.

Strassel's column ends with the warning,

"With Democrats actively recruiting conservative candidates, it's no longer good enough for the GOP names to fall back on cultural credentials, to demagogue immigration, or to simply promise lower taxes. Voters care about the size of government, but they are equally worried about the cost of doctor visits and gas prices. The winners will be those who explain the merits of a private health-care reform, who talk about vouchers, who push for energy production. And given its reputation on ethics, it's clear the GOP has to recruit Mr. Cleans, who also make voters believe they are more interested in solving problems than bringing home pork.

Mr. Jenkins's defeat says little about how Republicans will fare in defining Mr. Obama or local competitors this fall. It says plenty about how the GOP continues to define itself, and why it remains in trouble."


I think she's right on target. Conservatism is not, or doesn't have to be, about party or historic affiliations. It's about preferring sensible, less-government solutions to pressing social and economic challenges.

For what it's worth, this article sparked in me the hope that now, with some real choices on the table this year, and upcoming ones, about economics, defense, foreign policy and healthcare, the conservatism of Ronald Reagan can make a comeback.

I don't personally fault George Bush for failing as a President. I don't think he has. But the time hasn't been ripe for the idiots running the GOP to realize that people want solutions more than postures on single issues like abortion.

Now that the White House is up for grabs in a way that it hasn't been since 1952, perhaps conservatives and their typical partisan affiliation, the Republican party, can gain seats in Congress based upon their approach to problem solving, rather than grandstanding on issues that are more theoretical and less-impacting on a daily basis in most voters' lives.

In the end, perhaps more crisis, not less, is going to open the door to a resurgence of conservative values and legislators at the national level.

Wednesday, March 12, 2008

McGovern's Conversion To Conservatism

Last Friday's Wall Street Journal featured a remarkable editorial by George McGovern entitled "Freedom Means Responsibility." To read his latest piece is to, I believe, witness the final conversion of Senator McGovern into a man of truly conservative values.

Some passages from his editorial are,

"Nearly 16 years ago in these very pages, I wrote that "'one-size-fits all' rules for business ignore the reality of the market place." Today I'm watching some broad rules evolve on individual decisions that are even worse.

Under the guise of protecting us from ourselves, the right and the left are becoming ever more aggressive in regulating behavior. Much paternalist scrutiny has recently centered on personal economics, including calls to regulate subprime mortgages.

Health-care paternalism creates another problem that's rarely mentioned: Many people can't afford the gold-plated health plans that are the only options available in their states.

Buying health insurance on the Internet and across state lines, where less expensive plans may be available, is prohibited by many state insurance commissions. Despite being able to buy car or home insurance with a mouse click, some state governments require their approved plans for purchase or none at all. It's as if states dictated that you had to buy a Mercedes or no car at all.

Economic paternalism takes its newest form with the campaign against short-term small loans, commonly known as "payday lending.

With payday lending, people in need of immediate money can borrow against their future paychecks, allowing emergency purchases or bill payments they could not otherwise make. The service comes at the cost of a significant fee -- usually $15 for every $100 borrowed for two weeks. But the cost seems reasonable when all your other options, such as bounced checks or skipped credit-card payments, are obviously more expensive and play havoc with your credit rating.

Anguished at the fact that payday lending isn't perfect, some people would outlaw the service entirely, or cap fees at such low levels that no lender will provide the service. Anyone who's familiar with the law of unintended consequences should be able to guess what happens next."

That last line is amazing to read. I'm old enough to remember McGovern's run for the Presidency, so this is particularly sweet to read. Imagine him, a former ultra-liberal Democratic US Senator, acknowledging the 'law of unintended consequences.'

It harks back to his reflections on attempting to run a B&B some years ago. Whether he appeared on Firing Line with Bill Buckley, or merely wrote about it in the Journal, I recall that he seemed a truly chastened man. His admission of frustration in dealing with the very same laws and paternalistic attitude he had helped craft as a Senator was gratifying to watch.

McGovern closed his piece with these words,

"Since leaving office I've written about public policy from a new perspective: outside looking in. I've come to realize that protecting freedom of choice in our everyday lives is essential to maintaining a healthy civil society.

Why do we think we are helping adult consumers by taking away their options? We don't take away cars because we don't like some people speeding. We allow state lotteries despite knowing some people are betting their grocery money. Everyone is exposed to economic risks of some kind. But we don't operate mindlessly in trying to smooth out every theoretical wrinkle in life.

The nature of freedom of choice is that some people will misuse their responsibility and hurt themselves in the process. We should do our best to educate them, but without diminishing choice for everyone else."

I could not put it better myself. Nor, I think, could any conservative of longstanding beliefs in that vein.

Wednesday, March 5, 2008

My First Memory of William F. Buckley, Jr.

It's been a week since the death of William F. Buckley, Jr.

As a conservative, I would be remiss if I did not write something in his memory. This is a week late simply because I've been so busy with other matters.

In the intervening week, many media sources, especially mainstream print and network, have produced and aired/printed exhaustive treatments of Mr. Buckley's full and amazing life and influence on modern, post-WWII American politics.

Thus, I'll make my own small contribution a personal one.

Growing up in downstate Illinois about the time Mr. Buckley founded National Review, I, of course, had little knowledge of him in my pre-school years. However, as a late pre-teen, I was treated to live coverage of the Democratic National Convention being held just upstate from us, in Chicago, in 1968.

My very first awareness of Mr. Buckley came from his stint as the conservative half of the original 'Hannity & Colmes' team during that convention. ABC hired Buckley and Gore Vidal to represent conservative and liberal views, moderated, if you can call it that, by then-news anchor Howard K. Smith.

Originally, for this post, I expected to write about the exchange still etched in my memory. Then, I thought....YouTube!

And, what do you know, but to my wondering eyes appeared the clip of the very 3 minutes or so of my first memory of the late Mr. Buckley in action. Good thing, too, because I was off in my memory by four years. I thought this interaction occurred in 1964. But the content is just as I recalled.

So, without further introduction....

Buckley v. Gore at the 1968 Democratic National Convention on ABC



Note the era of conservative suits and somewhat restrained manners. Until, that is, Gore calls Buckley a 'crypto-Nazi.' Then Buckley lets loose on the live feed with words for which, today, he'd probably be called on to recant.


Ah, for the simpler times of old.....

As a further tribute to Mr. Buckley, here is a clip of him espousing his views on the necessary qualifications for the Oval Office occupant circa 1968. I think Buckley is still on target today, as well.

Additionally, this clip portrays Buckley behaving quintessentially. The verbiage, mannerisms and delivery are just classic.

Like Reagan, he'd been gone from the public scene for a while before his death. Never the less, I'll still miss him, as well.

Buckley on Presidential Qualifications for 1968





Still makes sense, doesn't it?

Sunday, December 9, 2007

Beware The Faux-Conservative: Mike Hickabee

Kim Strassel wrote a wonderful, informative piece about former Arkansas Governor Mike Huckabee in a recent edition of the Wall Street Journal. It's not the first of its ilk in the Journal, but it is somewhat more current, given Hick-abee's recent rise in polls in Iowa.

As in an earlier Journal piece, by which author I do not recall, Strassel provides details which demonstrate Hick-abee's lie, when he casts himself as a conservative.

He has a nearly-impossible plan to totally revise taxation in America, grandiosely calling for the abolition of the IRS.

As if.

He speaks of support for headline-type conservative positions, such as "lower taxes," a "strong America," and "health care reform." But his detailed, practical plans for such are missing.

Essentially, as another Arkansas Governor before him, Hick-abee is long on style, charisma and jocularity, but short on specifics.

Why should one run for President? To provide solutions not readily available. Why do candidates often run? Because they simply would like the job.

Of the Republicans, I think only Romney and Giuliani genuinely offer specifics on what they would do to handle various issues and problems which our nation currently faces.

I like Thompson but, truth be told, to back him is to back a style and attitude, more than positions and a record. As with the McCain, the maniacal Ron Paul, or Tancredo.

It's the same, I fear, with the latest hick from the South, Mike Hick-abee.

Sunday, October 14, 2007

Economic Visions: Conservatives vs. Liberals

You can write a lot about the differences on economic topics between American political conservatives and liberals.

However, in my opinion, there is one truly fundamental difference. I described it last week in this post on my companion business blog. In part, I wrote,

"I think this, frankly, is the central economic issue of the day.Government does not plan the economy. We don't, by and large, run a socialist or fascist economic system in America.

Instead, the idea is that government sets certain conditions of law, safety, taxation, etc., then lets individuals, either solely or collectively, decide how to operate within those parameters to pursue their dreams and achieve economic prosperity."

Conservatives understand that government sets up conditions for people to pursue their individual economic well-being and amass wealth. How that's done is up to the person, or groups of self-organized persons. Therefore, what government attempts to provide is opportunity, not work or jobs, per se. And certainly not the same job, in the same place, in perpetuity.



American political liberals, including most Democrats, and certainly the more extreme ones on both coasts, seem to play on economic misfortune, assuring the poor that by taxing the rich, the liberals will help the poor with some of that transferred wealth. The implication being,


'You are too poor and inept to help yourself. Just keep voting for us, and the subsidies will continue to flow.....'


When they aren't busy taxing the 'rich' to fund welfare payments to the 'poor,' these Democrats are trying to codify industrial policy, via, for example, legislated universal health care, mandated insurance policy coverages, various tariffs and subsidies. All of which serve to frustrate and distort the market pricing of goods, services, and, often, their inputs.

If these confounding legislative activities ceased, and market prices drove business activity, then people would be more easily able to understand and follow the flow of business activity to where it most profitably will occur.

The specific products produced on US shores may change, but it's always going to be in the interest of savvy entrepreneurs to use educated, productive Americans to provide goods or services at competitive prices, or on competitive service terms. In fact, it's not the dollar volume of American manufacturing production that has decreased over the past decades- it's just the number of jobs.

We've gotten more productive, and that's a good thing. The Democrats would insist that each old, less productive worker be retained and paid as before, no matter that there were more productive alternatives elsewhere.

We cannot manage an economy by attempting to control and price inputs. That simply drives business people away, to more flexible locations.

Instead, government needs to simply set consistent conditions for the conduct of business activity, then let those who risk capital figure out what will make them money.

Jack Welch actually managed to articulate a clear, succinct explanation of this last week in an interview on CNBC. When asked his opinion of Hillary's programs and candidacy, he shot back something like,

'I don't think her programs (to nationalize health care and insurance) will work. When have you ever seen government do something better than the private sector can do it?'

American has historically succeeded economically because of its flexibility and hospitality to new ideas. That's why immigrants come here to make a better life. And most do. Hispanic, Southeast Asian, Korean, Chinese. Before them, Germans, Scots, Irish, Poles, and Italians.


In the long run, I really don't think the liberal economic message, most recently articulated by Hillary, will sell. People like to believe they can escape poverty, provide better opportunities for their children, and earn a share of the American Dream

Candidates like Edwards, Obama and Hillary try to tell Americans that they are failing, hopeless, and bound for poverty. The truth is that our country's political economic fabric has done the opposite- it's provided the opportunity for literally millions of immigrants and citizens to move themselves from poverty to economic self-sufficiency, by participating in the globe's most dynamic, attractive economic zone.

As Roger Ailes noted in an interview with the Wall Street Journal, about which I wrote in this post,

"If you watch some news -- I always say to my people, when I see something particularly horrible about America that I think is a little out of proportion to what is actually going on, I call up the desk and say, "Do you have any pictures of people lined up at the border trying to get out?" They say, "What do you mean?" I say, "I just watched that and hell, we've got to get out of here, America's a terrible place. We need to get out fast. There must be guys stacked up at the airport trying to get out of here." No. It turns out everybody's trying to get in, and nobody's trying to get out. We've got to keep that perspective in mind when you cover the news. It doesn't mean you don't cover the bad news about America. You do. It means you don't get up in the morning hating your country. And so, until somebody shows me lines at the border trying to get out, I think there's some good news."

And that, dear readers, is how you know that Hillary, Obama, Edwards, Pelosi, and Harry Reid have the wrong idea about America, business and economic development. People are not lining up at our borders to leave, because economic conditions are so bad.

Instead, one of the biggest recent Congressional tussles has been how to set an immigration policy to deal with the rush of illegal entrants to our country, all trying to create their own version of the American Dream.

Really, it's a good, "high class" problem to have. So long as we continue to have a government that only sets economic conditions, rather than legislates business operations, this will continue to be true.

Monday, January 29, 2007

Liberals, Conservatives, and Caring for the Poor

Last week, newly-elected Senator Webb of Virginia did a lot of damage with his Democratic 'response' to President's State of the Union address. Webb has it wrong when he says that we have economic problems. This sort of continued negative spin on reality will result in bad policy.

Specifically, Webb alleged, like John Edwards during the 2004 Presidential campaign, that America is now two different countries, economically. They allege that part of America is poor, and growing poorer, not participating in the nation's healthy economic growth.

A recent piece in the Wall Street Journal by Arthur Brooks suggests why these Democrats view the situation in this manner. To wit, Brooks wrote,

"While just about everybody -- left and right -- agrees that poverty is unacceptable (although policy makers disagree as to whether a minimum wage hike would help or hurt the working poor), conservatives do not share liberals' concern about income inequality. According to the 2005 Maxwell Poll on Civic Engagement and Inequality, self-described liberals are more than twice as likely as conservatives to say income inequality in America is a "serious problem." And while 84% of liberals think the government should do more to reduce inequality, only 25% of conservatives agree.

This is empirical substantiation for the old cliché that conservatives just don't care about the poor, right? Wrong. In fact, the data do not tell us that conservatives are uncaring; they actually tell us that conservatives are optimists. Conservatives are relatively untroubled by inequality, and unsupportive of government income redistribution, because they believe the American economy provides private opportunities to succeed. Liberals are far more pessimistic than conservatives about the possibility of a better future for Americans of modest means.

Consider the evidence. While 92% of conservatives believe that hard work and perseverance can help a person overcome disadvantage, only 65% of liberals think so. This difference of opinion, contrary to the convention, is not because conservatives earn more money. In fact, lower-income conservatives are about twice as likely as upper-income liberals to say they think there's "a lot" of upward mobility in America. If a liberal and a conservative are exactly identical in income, education, sex, family situation, and race, the conservative will be 20 percentage points more likely than the liberal to say that hard work leads to success among the disadvantaged."


The data that Brooks cites matter profoundly. Both Webb and Edwards, and their ilk, are already biased to believe the worst about the economy and our society. They believe that income inequality is a major problem, and that nobody's individual efforts on their own behalf will lift them out of poverty.

Yet, we know from other studies, the exact ones which I do not have at hand to cite at the moment, that the income inequality numbers frequently cited by liberals are static, not dynamic. That is, they do not follow the same people for years, and find continued low incomes. Rather, they observe the lowest category of incomes, and, then, some years later, observe, 'yep, lookie there...some people are still poor." They simply assume the same people stayed in the same categories. In a word, pessimistic, as Brooks notes.

Nevermind that he Reagan revolution led to a broad middle group of politically-left-leaning voters to experience the economic fruits of lower taxes and healthy, low-inflation economic growth. It's as if those years never occurred, Reagan's recovery never happened, and nobody ever gets wealthier in America from hard work and diligence.

Conservatives do care about the poor. We simply feel that low tax rates, robust, low-inflationary growth, and fairness for all maximize everyone's opportunity for self-improvement and wealth-enhancement.